The publish on the Good Housekeeping web site was titled “8 Dog Food Brands Vets Actually Recommend.” Good Housekeeping consulted with two veterinarians for his or her pet meals suggestions, Dr. Alejandro Caos and Dr. Megan Conrad.
Their primary “Finest General” decide for pet food was Nutro Extremely Dry Canine Meals. Dr. Caos said about this model: “The crunchy texture will help promote dental well being,” he says. “The mechanical motion of chewing kibble will help scale back tartar buildup and keep more healthy enamel and gums, whereas the abrasive motion of chewing will help scrape away plaque.”
Sadly, Dr. Caos’s assertion isn’t true. Kibble/dry pet food doesn’t scale back tartar buildup. A canine or cat chewing typical kibble doesn’t scrape away plaque. There are some kibble pet meals that do meet veterinary standards to make the declare of tartar discount, this pet food isn’t considered one of them.
The identical veterinarian within the Good Housekeeping publish gave this details about what’s essential in deciding on a pet meals: “Wholesome pet food ought to present balanced vitamin, use high-quality components, promote correct digestion, and be appropriate on your canine’s life stage and any distinctive dietary concerns.”
This assertion is smart, nevertheless it’s a normal assertion that doesn’t present pet house owners with a lot help. What are ‘high-quality ingredients’?
The opposite veterinarian consulted for the Good Housekeeping publish, Dr. Conrad, “extremely recommends” Purina ProPlan stating this pet food is “one of the vital nutritionally balanced choices available on the market.” What does she imply by “nutritionally balanced”? Why is that this pet food extra ‘nutritionally balanced’ than most different canine meals?
In all of the pet meals Good Housekeeping beneficial, just one is human grade (Ollie Pet Meals). However…Good Housekeeping and their veterinarians didn’t clarify to pet house owners the distinction with this meals than all the opposite manufacturers beneficial (human grade vs all others are feed grade), they solely said the Ollie pet meals was “homemade-looking dinners.”
Disappointing.
The Good Housekeeping web site states: “For greater than 125 years, Good Housekeeping has been evaluating merchandise and advocating for customers.” On this case, Good Housekeeping and the veterinarians they consulted with dropped the ball.
Sadly, Good Housekeeping and the veterinarians they consulted with have most likely by no means been to an AAFCO assembly, don’t personal the pet meals laws rule guide (the AAFCO Official Publication), and are unaware that the FDA has ever made public statements much like this: “We don’t imagine that using diseased animals or animals that died in any other case than by slaughter to make animal meals poses a security concern and we intend to proceed to train enforcement discretion.” We now have to imagine that Good Housekeeping and their veterinarians have no idea there are feed grade components and human grade components utilized in pet meals.
However they need to know.
We despatched Good Housekeeping an electronic mail explaining how their pet meals recommendation might mislead pet house owners.
With the veterinarians Good Housekeeping consulted with, their phrases weren’t a lot totally different than what many veterinarians inform pet house owners each day. Their phrases don’t make them unhealthy veterinarians, it solely exhibits they don’t seem to be knowledgeable about pet meals.
In case your veterinarian makes statements just like the above, ask them questions. What do you imply by ‘high quality components’? Are they human grade or feed grade components? What do you imply by ‘one of the vital nutritionally balanced choices’? Do you may have peer reviewed science to proof that? Are you able to share it with me?
Preserve talking up. Be respectful, tactfully maintain them accountable for his or her pet meals recommendation.
Susan Thixton
Pet Meals Shopper Advocate
TruthaboutPetFood.com
Association for Truth in Pet Food
Discover Wholesome Pet Meals in Your Space Click Here
The 2026 Record
Our trusted ‘listing’ of pet meals. Click Here to be taught extra.
The 2026/27 Deal with Record
Susan’s Record of trusted pet deal with producers. Click Here to be taught extra.
Affiliation for Fact in Pet Meals is a stakeholder group representing pet meals customers at AAFCO and with FDA. Your membership helps representatives attend conferences and voice shopper issues with regulatory authorities. Click Here to be taught extra.
