Who’s Kenn? Merely put, Kenn is a nationwide treasure. A famend birder, writer, and conservationist, Kenn Kaufman has spent his life devoted to observing birds, studying about birds, writing about birds, and sharing the world of birds with others. With all that birdy data in his mind, he additionally acts as the sector editor for Audubon journal. So, every time now we have a chicken query stumping us across the workplace, we simply ask Kenn. And now you may, too! When you have a chicken or birding query you would like Kenn to reply, depart them on Fb or ship us an electronic mail. Possibly subsequent month you may get the form of thorough, considerate, and even humorous response from Kenn we have grown so keen on over time. —The Editors
***
Q: I need to enhance my flycatcher ID expertise, however I hold getting tripped up. Why are some flycatchers so onerous to determine? Is there a secret?
Kenn: I usually inform people who understanding why a species is troublesome to determine may be the important thing to creating an ID. Flycatchers are the proper instance of this concept.
Birds, like different creatures, should be capable to acknowledge their very own form, not less than throughout the breeding season. Whereas another animals might determine potential mates by scent or different chemical cues, birds typically depend on sight and sound. That’s good for us—for human birders—as a result of we will study to zero in on these identical seen and audible clues to inform species aside. However teams of birds that rely primarily on sound can current excessive ID challenges for us, particularly after they’re silent.
No birds illustrate this higher than the tyrant flycatchers (household Tyrannidae). Discovered solely within the Americas, that is nonetheless one of many world’s largest chicken households, with properly over 400 species. And though some are distinctive—just like the good crimson male Vermilion Flycatcher or the elegantly adorned Scissor-tailed Flycatcher—most are drab, and there are various teams during which all of the species look just about the identical.
However voice stays essentially the most dependable clue for all of them.
Flycatchers are principally tropical, and solely about 33 species happen often north of the Mexican border (with not less than one other 14 straying in from farther south). However even this lowered choice contains a number of troublesome species pairs or teams. Japanese and Western Wooden-Pewees are nearly similar to one another. The identical is true for Tropical and Sofa’s Kingbirds. A number of of the crested flycatchers within the genus Myiarchus, particularly people who overlap within the Southwest, are very comparable. After which there are the ten small Empidonax flycatchers, perpetually problematic for North American birders.
Prior to now, a few of these birds have been thought of unattainable to separate visually. Advances in latest many years have helped birders to see refined structural factors, like invoice shapes and wingtip lengths, to tease these downside species aside. However voice stays essentially the most dependable clue for all of them—extra so than for every other household of birds in North America.
Contemplate two Empidonax species, Willow Flycatcher and Alder Flycatcher. These two are so comparable that they have been considered one species, known as “Traill’s Flycatcher,” till 1973. Slight variations enable some typical people to be separated visually—however even at a banding station, the place the birds may be examined within the hand, many nonetheless should be dismissed as “Traill’s.” Their voices, nevertheless, are diagnostic. (See illustration left.) Willow Flycatcher sings FITZ-bew, with the accent on the primary, snappy syllable of the track. Alder Flycatcher sings zee-BEEoh, with emphasis on the second syllable earlier than a slight slur. The distinction within the songs is refined (which explains why it was ignored for therefore lengthy), however it’s simple to listen to, with sufficient follow.
Even their callnotes are distinctive. Willow Flycatcher provides a pointy, thick Whit that appears to have its hardest sound on the finish. The comparable be aware from Alder Flycatcher is a softer, flatter Kep. Written descriptions convey solely a poor thought of the variations, however they’re simple to listen to in good recordings. In contrast to the songs, that are given primarily by males on the breeding grounds, these callnotes could also be heard at any time of yr, from females or males.
There’s a purpose why voice is essential for ID of so many lookalikes on this household. Flycatchers are completely different, vocally, from all our different birds. They’re categorized within the order Passeriformes, the perching birds or songbirds, which incorporates every little thing from wrens to ravens. However inside that order, flycatchers are positioned in a definite group, the suboscines, usually thought of barely extra primitive. The primary distinction is of their vocal equipment—they’ve a lot easier muscle tissues controlling their syrinx, or sound-producing organ. So they could be bodily unable to provide actually advanced, melodious songs.
In addition they develop their songs in a different way. For typical songbirds, there is a component of studying concerned. They might have an inner template, however they received’t ever totally develop the track of their species except they hear it first. Flycatchers are completely different: their songs are hard-wired of their intuition. In a traditional set of research, Willow Flycatchers and Alder Flycatchers have been raised in a lab, by no means listening to the songs of their very own form. Some have been uncovered to the voice of the alternative species, with younger Alders listening to recordings of Willow songs, for instance. Even so, the males all grew as much as sing what have been described as “remarkably regular” songs of their very own species, proving that these have been innate and never discovered.
Thus, in lots of teams of flycatchers, people don’t want to have the ability to acknowledge their very own species by sight alone. Whether or not they can acknowledge one another visually is an open query! However the message for birders is that voice is commonly every little thing to creating a profitable ID. And in case you‘re taking a look at a silent flycatcher, the right and solely identification is perhaps “I don’t know.”
